Tag Archives: socialism

The status quo results in socialism

Is America heading toward socialism? Is President Obama taking us there? Will the tea party save us?

I think the first question that must be asked is: What will happen if American does nothing? Forget about all the proposals for new government spending. Forget about tax policy for a second. What will happen if America simply maintains the status quo, without growing or reducing the size of government?

According to the Congressional Budget Office’s 2011 Long-Term Budget Outlook, the federal government will consume 34.1 to 75.9 percent of GDP in 2085. The lower number is called “The Extended-Baseline Scenario” while the higher number is “The Alternative Fiscal Scenario,” which includes the extension of the tax cuts set to expire, rising debt levels, and “spiraling interest payments.”

Add in current state and local spending, subtracting out governmental transfers, (that assumes state and local government do not grow, as they have done for the last 100 years) government at all levels will consume 49.7  to 91.5 percent of GDP in 2085.

Even with the CBO’s optimistic forecast, government will account for half of all economic activity. Currently, government accounts for about 40.9 percent of our economy. But the pessimistic outlook from the CBO has the government controlling nearly all of the economy. We will be fully socialist!

Unfortunately, I lean toward the more pessimistic outlook. And I’m not alone. The CBO writes:

Many budget analysts believe that the alternative fiscal scenario presents a more realistic picture of the nation’s underlying fiscal policies than the extended-baseline scenario does. The explosive path of federal debt under the alternative fiscal scenario underscores the need for large and rapid policy changes to put the nation on a sustainable fiscal course.

Looking at the accompanying spreadsheet, the CBO has unemployment falling to an average of 8.4% next year, then falling to 7.6% in 2013, 6.8% in 2014, 5.9% in 2015, 5.3% in 2016, 5.2% in 2019, 5.1% in 2026, and 5.0% in 2030 where it stays forever. Oh really? They really expect unemployment to average 5.0% from 2016 to 2085? Has the United States or any country ever had sustained low unemployment uninterrupted by recession for 70 consecutive years? I don’t think so!

Certainly, the Baseline Scenario is too optimistic. This means that even with no new government programs, government will account for well over half of all economic activity by 2085. In this Alternative Scenario, the CBO estimates that government at all level would consume nearly all of economic output.

Socialism is in our future if we do not change. Doing nothing–merely blocking new government programs–is not enough. We must undo the damage that has already been done and fix the government programs that are already eating up a growing percentage of our national production.

– Michael E. Newton is the author of the highly acclaimed The Path to Tyranny: A History of Free Society’s Descent into Tyranny. His newest book, Angry Mobs and Founding Fathers: The Fight for Control of the American Revolution, was released by Eleftheria Publishing in July.

Another trailer for The Path to Tyranny

The Path to Tyranny book trailer

Portugal and Spain deny need for aid, but it doesn’t matter what they think or say.

Even if the MSM and government officials did not see this coming, you and I certainly did.  Marketwatch reports:

Portuguese and Spanish officials scrambling Friday to head off speculation that Lisbon or Madrid could soon be forced to seek help to meet their borrowing needs.

A spokesman for the Portuguese government said a report in the Financial Times Deutschland newspaper — that Lisbon was under pressure from the European Central Bank and a majority of euro-zone countries to seek a bailout in order to ease pressure on Spain — was “totally false,” news reports said.

Meanwhile, Spanish Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero said in a radio interview that he “absolutely” ruled out a rescue for Spain, saying the nation’s deficit-reduction measures were well under way and that the economy, while still weak, has touched bottom.

OK, so Portugal and Spain continue to deny their need for a bailout or loans from the EU or IMF. Nothing new there. But the market disagrees:

The yield premium demanded by investors to hold 10-year Spanish bonds over German bunds widened to a record 2.63 percentage points as Spain’s 10-year yield continued to climb above 5.10%.

The cost of protecting Portuguese and other peripheral euro-zone sovereign debt against default through credit default swaps, or CDS, continued to rise.

The spread on five-year Portuguese CDS widened by 20 basis points to 500 basis points, according to data provider Markit. That means it would cost $500,000 annually to insure $10 million of Portuguese debt against default for five years, up from $480,000 on Thursday.

The euro fell to a two-month low versus the dollar to change hands at $1.3236 in recent action.

Portugal, with 10-year bond yields above 7%, was long seen as the next most likely candidate to seek a bailout after Ireland. Borrowing costs under the EFSF are seen at around 5% to 6% over three years.

Uh oh! As I wrote in a previous post:

Spain, Portugal, and Italy may not be in trouble, but if people start thinking they are “at risk,” they’ll withdraw their funds and it will become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Technically speaking, Portugal and Spain may not need help right now, but they will most certainly need help if interest rates rise too much. But the report continues:

News reports, meanwhile, said that Germany this week rejected a suggestion by the European Commission to double the size of Europe’s 440 billion euro ($588 billion) bailout fund for euro-zone governments. The euro-zone contribution is part of the total €750 billion rescue program put in place with the International Monetary Fund in the spring.

Will Europe be willing and able to bail out Spain if it comes to that? Germany appears to be having second thoughts. Why should Germany waste its money bailing out another country? More so, how much money did Spain contribute to the bailouts of Greece and Ireland as part of the EU, money it no longer has to fix its own problems? Germany may want to keep its cash just in case it needs it.

In fact, Germany is one of the best fiscal situations in the entire world. Yet even it is balking. As Margaret Thatcher reported said, “The trouble with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.” Ireland and Greece have used up much of Europe’s money and good will. Now, there is a lot less left for Portugal and Spain.

Good luck Europe.

Chinese bubble about to burst?

The Chinese market fell sharply today, the second time in three sessions, as China tries to slow down its economy:

Chinese stocks suffered sharp declines Tuesday, with property developers tumbling on further tightening measures that target the sector, while coal and metal shares fell on concerns about price curbs.

Chinese property stocks fell sharply after Beijing on Monday announced new limits on the ability of foreigners to buy residential or commercial property.

Chinese refining, coal and metal stocks stumbled after the China Securities Journal, citing unnamed sources, reported that the country might unveil a set of measures in the near term to control rising prices.

China is in the midst of a huge bubble, quite possibly the largest bubble ever anywhere. There have been numerous reports of entire cities built in China that now sit empty. See here, here, and here for example. There are reportedly 64 million empty apartments in China.

China is now in the process of deflating its bubble. It hopes to prick the bubble without suffering an economic collapse. But this is unlikely to occur. Despite all the building and growth, China is still a poor country. The vast majority live in poverty and the middle class is much poorer than the American middle class. Despite its relatively lack of wealth and, correspondingly, capital, China has spent hundreds of billions on wasteful projects that now sit idle. [How much money was spent building 64 million apartments that now sit idle?] The US housing bubble pales in comparison, yet the US economy is three times the size and is better able to survive such waste.

When the Chinese bubble bursts, it will take down much of the world with it. With Ireland, Greece, Portugal, and Spain already on edge and the US suffering from a weak economy, huge deficits, and growing debt, the world economy can hardly afford another burst bubble at this point. But what are the options? Prolonging the bubble only makes the pain worse when it does burst. Better to take our medicine now and return to reality as soon as possible.

The Path to Tyranny featured on Conservative Bookstore!

The Conservative Bookstore is featuring my book, The Path to Tyranny: A History of Free Society’s Descent into Tyranny, on their site this month.

W.J. Rayment of the Conservative Bookstore posted the full review at Conservative Monitor. Here is the full review for you enjoyment:

Even in the days of ancient Greece, political science was a subject earnestly studied and remarkably well-understood. The multiplicity of city states allowed philosophers to discern patterns in the ebb and flow of historical events. What the Solon’s of the age noticed was that when pure democracy was allowed to reign in any state that the inevitable result was a rapid destruction of the economy and a sudden move to tyranny coupled with an almost complete loss of liberty.

Michael E Newton in his seminal work, The Path to Tyranny: A History of Free Society’s Descent into Tyranny, we are treated to historical examples of what happens when a society allows rampant, uncontrolled democracy to subvert constitutional balance within a government. Newton begins with ancient Western Civilization where in both Greek and Roman society broke down because the mass of people figured out they could violate property rights through the government. When this happened, productivity was discouraged by ever rising taxation. The declining availability of goods and services caused the frustration of the under-classes (because that an exploited economy could not support their demands). Thus, they would resort to a demagogic dictator who would ring society dry for the support of the masses in the aggrandizement of his own wealth and power.

As The Path to Tyranny so ably illustrates, in example after example, the ultimate result of this process is the loss of freedom, the degradation of the economy, and general misery. This is one of those history books where Santayana’s famous quote rings loud and rings true, “Those who do not understand history are doomed to repeat it.” There are lessons here for America. Mr. Newton’s clear and concise writing style makes them crystal clear.

This is the great thing about this book. It can be understood by both the academic as well as the layman. As a student of history myself (I wrote a textbook on Modern European History), I found myself gesticulating, scribbling in the margins, and generally agreeing with point after point. I kept thinking that this book is irrefutable. I can’t imagine an academic or politician arguing intelligently with Newton’s assertions or his conclusions. Of course, there are three self-interested groups who would argue that America’s present course is a good one. They would be those who believe they will benefit from government largesse in the form of welfare payments, “free” health care, and social security. Then there are those academics who arrogantly think they are smart enough to manage a centralized economy better than Smith’s invisible hand. Finally, most ominously, there are those politicians who wish to harness the lazy greed of those who would suck off the system, using it to propel their own political careers in a tyrannical direction…Ironically, in the U.S. most of these politicians are currently called Democrats.

The Path to Tyranny is well-documented – with ample citations, a bibliography, and a comprehensive index. Besides ancient Greece and Rome, it covers ancient Israel, Communist Russia, Fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, and of course the current state of affairs in the United States. In a fascinating section, Newton also nails the dictatorship of Hugo Chavez. After reading this book anyone who subscribes to the democratic agenda, must be stupid, delusional, or a demagogue!

Must Read!

Thank you Mr. Rayment for your great review. I’m glad you enjoyed the book.

ELEFTHERIA I THANATOS!

Enumerated Powers Amendment for the Constitution

In addition to repealing the 16th and 17th Amendments and getting rid of the Federal Reserve (all of which began in 1913), I propose this new Amendment:

The federal government shall have no powers beyond those specifically enumerated in the Constitution or absolutely required for the enforcement of those enumerated powers.

The general welfare and commerce clauses do not give the federal government any powers beyond those specifically expressed elsewhere in the Constitution.

All commitments and liabilities of the United States must be honored and paid out either immediately or in their due course. No new commitments or liabilities from unconstitutional programs may be added after the ratification of this amendment.

If anybody has suggestions to improve this amendment, feel free to comment below or email me from the contact page.